We analysed the Amazon.co.uk subcategory Dressing & Spice Dispensers and kept only products with at least 200 reviews and 4.3 stars. Ranked by estimated monthly revenue, eight of the ten are salt and pepper mills cross-filed from the mill categories — only the nine-pot spice tin at rank 4 and the 24-jar set at rank 7 are storage in the sense the category name suggests.
The revenue leader is a grinder you buy for what is inside it: 390 g of pink salt at £8.99, sold from the UK and moving over 1,500 units a month.
Check the price on AmazonThe revenue leader is a grinder you buy for what is inside it: 390 g of pink salt at £8.99, sold from the UK and moving over 1,500 units a month.
With 13,536 reviews the most reviewed listing in this comparison, and a battery pair that also tops the Pepper Mills ranking rather than anything resembling a dispenser.
The most expensive listing here at £57.68 — a fourth finish of the Derwent pair, which elsewhere on Amazon sells at £43 in stainless, £55.86 in matt black and £73.29 in matt gold.
The one entry built purely for holding spice: nine lidded pots inside a 22.5 cm tin, although its price rose 60% over the observed period.
A single rechargeable mill at £14.99 whose selling point is the refill opening on top, so nothing has to be unscrewed underneath and tipped out.
A USB pair on a storage base at £20.99, and the only listing on this page that says the container can be washed rather than just wiped.
The best value per container here: 24 square 120 ml jars for £21.24, which works out under 90p a jar including the shaker inserts.
At £44.99 the dearest of the electric pairs in this list, and the only entry sitting right on the 4.3-star floor of the comparison.
A single manual mill sold on not leaving a ring of grounds where it stands, which counts for something in a category of containers that live out on show.
The two-mill version of rank 5 at £25.70 after a 28% drop, with the coarseness dial on the outside so it can be changed mid-grind.
| Product | Score | Stars | Reviews | Feature | Material | Price | Offer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01. Silk Route Pink Salt Grinder, 390 g Best seller Silk Route Spice Company · Silk Route Spice Company |
9.0 | 4.6 ★ | 2,996 | pre-filled · 390 g | Plastic | £8.99 | Amazon › |
| 02. Russell Hobbs Electric Salt & Pepper Mill Set Russell Hobbs · Russell Hobbs |
9.1 | 4.4 ★ | 13,536 | electric · ceramic | Stainless steel | £20.99 | Amazon › |
| 03. Cole & Mason Derwent Mill Set, Gunmetal Top rated Cole & Mason · Cole & Mason |
9.3 | 4.8 ★ | 2,478 | gunmetal · 190 mm | Stainless steel | £57.68 | Amazon › |
| 04. BUB Masala Dabba Spice Tin, 9 Pots BUB · BUB |
8.3 | 4.5 ★ | 341 | 9 pots · 22.5 cm | Stainless steel | £27.99 | Amazon › |
| 05. CIRCLE JOY Electric Pepper Grinder, Top-Refill CIRCLE JOY · CIRCLE JOY |
8.4 | 4.6 ★ | 355 | top-refill · single | Stainless steel | £14.99 | Amazon › |
| 06. iWarmbase Electric Salt & Pepper Grinder Set iWarmbase · iWarmbase |
8.2 | 4.4 ★ | 379 | USB · washable | Stainless steel | £20.99 | Amazon › |
| 07. ComSaf Glass Spice Jars, 24-pack, 120 ml ComSaf · ComSaf |
8.8 | 4.7 ★ | 932 | 24-pack · 120 ml | Glass and bamboo | £21.24 | Amazon › |
| 08. LARS NYSØM Electric Mill Set, Carbon Black LARS NYSØM · LARS NYSØM |
8.6 | 4.3 ★ | 3,574 | USB · LED light | Stainless steel | £44.99 | Amazon › |
| 09. OXO Good Grips Mess-Free Pepper Grinder OXO · OXO |
9.2 | 4.6 ★ | 5,546 | single · mess-free | Stainless steel | £23.79 | Amazon › |
| 10. CIRCLE JOY Electric Mill Set, Silver CIRCLE JOY · CIRCLE JOY |
8.7 | 4.6 ★ | 890 | external adjuster | Stainless steel | £25.70 | Amazon › |
Three exits appear in this list: a grinder cap, a shaker insert with holes, and an open pour. Shaker holes suit dried herbs and ground paprika, a grinder is for whole crystal and seed, and an open neck is only useful when you are measuring into a spoon.
Most mills unscrew at the bottom, which means turning a full container upside down over the worktop. Rank 5 is sold specifically on filling from the top, and the jar set at rank 7 ships with a funnel. Small details, but they decide whether refilling is tidy or a spillage.
A masala dabba keeps nine spices in a single lidded tin you carry to the hob one-handed. Separate jars label better, stack better and can be replaced one at a time. The tin wins for the six or seven spices you reach for daily; jars win for a full rack.
Ground spice loses its aroma to air and daylight, so how well the lid seals matters more than what the jar is made of. Bamboo lids look better than plastic but depend on a separate liner for the seal — worth a look on a 24-pack you intend to refill for years.
Square jars stand flush in a drawer and on a rack; round mills and tins do not. Measure the drawer depth and the shelf height before ordering a 24-piece set, because 120 ml jars only save space if they stand upright where you meant to put them.
Rank 1 is sold for its contents: 390 g of pink salt in a body that is not really built to be reopened. Convenient once, expensive to repeat. A refillable mill plus a bag of crystals costs more on day one and less by the third refill.
Amazon lists the same mills under Pepper Mills, Salt Mills and this node at the same time, and on revenue they swamp everything else. Eight of the ten highest-earning listings here grind. The genuine storage products are the nine-pot tin at rank 4 and the 24-jar set at rank 7.
A dabba keeps your everyday spices together and moves from cupboard to hob in one hand, but the pots are unlabelled and refilled by eye. Separate jars label cleanly, stack in a drawer and can be replaced individually. Here the tin is £27.99 for nine pots and the jar set £21.24 for twenty-four.
It is convenient the first time and poor value afterwards. The £8.99 grinder at rank 1 is priced for the 390 g of salt inside it rather than for the mechanism. If you grind salt daily, a refillable mill and loose crystals works out cheaper within a few refills.
The products are ordered by estimated monthly revenue per ASIN, not by star rating and not by bestseller rank. Only products with at least 200 reviews and an average of 4.3 stars were included. Because mills are cross-filed into this node and sell in far greater volume, they push the actual dispensers down the list.
The score is not our own hands-on test. It is calculated transparently from public Amazon data: 75% from the average star rating and 25% from the number of reviews, weighted logarithmically. The ranking order itself comes from estimated monthly revenue per ASIN. Prices, ratings and review counts were retrieved from Amazon.co.uk on 22 July 2026 and can change at any time.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you. All links are affiliate links. Prices are snapshots taken on 22 July 2026; the current price is shown live on Amazon. Product images and details come from Amazon or the manufacturers.